Worse than Straker and Horwood?

Based on 20 minutes of  watching straker playing, definitely worse!

Really?!

Quoted from Mariner Ronnie

Based on 20 minutes of  watching straker playing, definitely worse!

Really?!

He came on with twenty to go on the right wing ( he`s normally a left sided player) then was shunted to left back in his first match in a new team that was playing like strangers, not a time to form any judgement of a new player

At least straker tried to take his man on twice he just forgot to take the ball with him.

I also noticed that Straker lost the ball on the right hand side outside the 18 yd box and did not try to win it back - did anyone else notice that?  I hope that's not a sign of things to come.

An idle player chris, was told he is a very lazy player and even in the warm up his body language was not exactly positive.

Well we will see.

Quoted from Mariner Ronnie

Based on 20 minutes of  watching straker playing, definitely worse!

Really?!

Do you mean East is definitely worse than Straker?

A player as versatile as East should always be on the bench.

Quoted from chaos33

Do you mean East is definitely worse than Straker?

No I meant your post was ridiculous to judge a player by watching him for 20 minutes.

Ronnie about 20 york fans have said the same thing about him in his overall play.

I know exactly what you mean about not judging until we see him but i will take other fans opinions on board.

Its ok when its all positive and fine and dandy but sometimes a player turns out to be excatly what he has been at his previous clubs.

Quoted from Abdul19

A player as versatile as East should always be on the bench.

Totally agree with this Abdul, he's a cracking player for this league, unless he's injured surely he should at least make the bench.

Quoted from Mariner Ronnie

No I meant your post was ridiculous to judge a player by watching him for 20 minutes.

I'm not judging a player. I'm asking a question. I haven't expressed an opinion.
You might want to edit your post.

Quoted from jonnyboy82

Ronnie about 20 york fans have said the same thing about him in his overall play.

I know exactly what you mean about not judging until we see him but i will take other fans opinions on board.

Its ok when its all positive and fine and dandy but sometimes a player turns out to be excatly what he has been at his previous clubs.

Let's just wait and see, he may be another Nolan.

Another Nolan? Really????

Quoted from blasty

Another Nolan? Really????

In terms of not judging a book by its cover, we wasn't over exuberant about him coming, but he turned out to be not a bad signing at the mo. The same should apply to straker. Give him another game or too before we write him off, or in :)

Kin ell another nolan ?

I love it all of a sudden nolan has turned us into this dynamic team, what has he done to make him this brilliant player.

Genuine question , why is nolan getting all this praise ,has he done owt clay cant do.

Its not exactly that he has made us win 4 on the trot is it ?

I think you and a few others need to actually bring yourselves into reality that he aint ran the show.

Quoted from jonnyboy82

Kin ell another nolan ?

I love it all of a sudden nolan has turned us into this dynamic team, what has he done to make him this brilliant player.

Genuine question , why is nolan getting all this praise ,has he done owt clay cant do.

Its not exactly that he has made us win 4 on the trot is it ?

I think you and a few others need to actually bring yourselves into reality that he aint ran the show.

I agree. We looked like a more solid team with Clay. We kept the ball better too. Very unlucky to lose his place.

Quoted from jonnyboy82

Kin ell another nolan ?

I love it all of a sudden nolan has turned us into this dynamic team, what has he done to make him this brilliant player.

Genuine question , why is nolan getting all this praise ,has he done owt clay cant do.

Its not exactly that he has made us win 4 on the trot is it ?

I think you and a few others need to actually bring yourselves into reality that he aint ran the show.

Yes.